First phase proposals review
May 25, 2013
Publishing the judge's comments to select or not to select proposals in first phase could be more useful. Primarily It can help authors, whose proposals are not selected for next phase to modify and proceed further with their idea. Secondarily it can improve openness of the Climate Colab.
May 26, 2013
Agreed - expert feedback on proposals is reason enough to participate in competitions! This would be very useful.
May 27, 2013
Thanks,let's hope for availability of that feature in present phase itself. Other wise I think we should stress for that, like feature request or petition.
May 28, 2013
We may not be able to comment on proposals that are incomplete or do not adhere to the contest guidelines. But we will do our best to provide feedback on all other proposals during the first phase of judging. Robert Laubacher For the Climate CoLab team
May 29, 2013
Thank you very much, that will be great. May be template kind (Radio buttons) points for various selection or non selection criteria in each proposal page which can ticked by judges as feedback can be tried. A suggestion which can considerably ease tedious task of feedback for each proposal.