Since there are no currently active contests, we have switched Climate CoLab to read-only mode.
Learn more at https://climatecolab.org/page/readonly.
Skip navigation
12comments
Share conversation: Share via:

Hannah Payne

Mar 30, 2015
09:28

Fellow


1 |
Share via:
Hi Jim, Interesting proposal! Thanks for submitting! I look forward to seeing further developments on this proposal, especially who you envision taking action on this idea. Cheers! Hannah

Jim Wright

Apr 1, 2015
01:00

Member


2 |
Share via:
Proposal
contributor
Hi, Hannah, Very many thanks for your encouraging remarks. There is still a long way to go, but I think the 40-odd days outstanding should be enough! I am trying to construct a single coherent message from the miscellaneous posts (essays, really) on my website at reengineering.com, converting my ideas from an Australiacentric approach to a world-wide one. As to who will take action, I hope to be able to point out opportunities for everyone from the United Nations down to activist groups and crowdsourcers. I hope also to build in a connection to sustainable population, which of course is an important component of the climate change model. Given your own interest in urban planning (yes, I had a peak at your profile!) you might find the post "Urban Landscape For A New Era" on my website to be of particular interest. Regards, Jim W.

Alexandra Gavilano

Apr 1, 2015
04:19

Fellow


3 |
Share via:
Wow, this sounds liek a very great idea. I am looking forward to read more about it. My suggestion is that it might be more realistic to go step-wise by the implementation, so the projetc actually c an be realized by your group, resp. other target groups. You might want to refer to the final goal of realizing this projetc worldwide, but you start with defined target groups on a regional level. I wish you all the best, Alexandra

Hemant Wagh

Apr 1, 2015
04:10

Member


4 |
Share via:
Hello Sir, Kindly consider adding to your tools, addition being a different approach to Fruit-Seeds, detailed in a proposal link to which is below. https://www.climatecolab.org/web/guest/plans/-/plans/contestId/1300103/phaseId/1300102/planId/1310401 Kindly try to utilize the theme, Thanks & Sincere Regards.

Jim Wright

Apr 2, 2015
08:45

Member


5 |
Share via:
Proposal
contributor
Thanks, colleagues all, for your kind interest. Hannah, I responded to your comment with such excitement that I mistyped my blogsite name. It is actually reengineeringaustraliaq.com. Alexandra, the "project" in the first instance is to set up the database and populate it with all of the information we can muster from known sources such as satellite scanning. The next step is to get as many people and organisations to look at the material and hold up their hands if they have any proposals on climate-friendly work to be done within their fields of interest. Next, we look at the relative values of single proposals or (preferably) groups of proposals close enough to be serviced by a single project. Finally, we try and marshal resources (including money!) all the way down the list from governments to crowdsourcing to complete the projects. Some of my "tools" are actually suggestions on economical ways to build transport, dams, housing and suchlike to give a worthwhile life to the people on the ground (whether temporarily or permanently). Hemant, your proposal regarding the recapture and reuse of fruit seeds would fit quite well within my concept. I can go a little further and combine your ideas with water conservation. I designed an underground car park with a special shape of roof which allowed trees and lawns to be grown over it. It was very economical to construct because of the repetitive nature of the shape. Water dams can take away useful agricultural land, but if a dam is covered with a similar roof, the space over the dam could be used for agriculture (including fruit trees!) and to increase water yield by up to 30% because of the prevention of evaporation. Best regards to you all. It is a privilege to be able to participate in this extraordinary world of ideas. Jim W.

Hannah Payne

Apr 21, 2015
10:54

Fellow


6 |
Share via:
Hi Jim, Thanks for sharing your blog - interesting stuff! The updates to your proposal are intriguing but the scope is still quite large. Is there a way to clarify the scope of the project or perhaps just present the first step of the process as the focus of the Climate CoLab Contest? As Alexandra mentioned, the judges will be looking for implementable projects that can be realized by yourself and/or affiliated groups. Best, Hannah

Jim Wright

Apr 23, 2015
12:11

Member


7 |
Share via:
Proposal
contributor
Hi, Hannah, There is only one implementable feature to start with and that is the audit database. I originally conceived it as a way of identifying sustainable population limits in Australia based on varying levels of land recovery, agricultural improvements and so on. Once it is in place and thrown open to interested organisations and members of the public with information to offer, the way is open to effect climate change improvement in two directions. One is to identify multiple usages for individual BLUs to optimise their potential value. The other is to find BLUs all over the world which have similar features which would justify larger investments in climate change amelioration processes suitable for all. Actually, I think I know where you are coming from. It is a little bit too diffused, which is partially due to the limited amount of words the proposal has to be fitted into. I recently went back and looked at some of the material I had collected and found that my concept sprang from the activities of people like Robert Vincin and Tony Rinaudo who have rescued thousands of hectares of derelict land in Africa and Asia by planting trees and other vegetation which use C4 carbon. The other potential activities such as building communities, agriculture and so forth are adjunct operations to help justify the expense or provide income and shelter to people engaged on the land recovery (and any other operations reducing climate change effects). I am currently doing a bit of a rewrite along the above lines which might be more to your liking. The target will be essentially carbon capture by various means with other activities offering support. The transport, housing and other ideas (all useful tools!) will be thrown in as an addendum to combat criticism about the difficulties of working in remote areas (even though we really need every bit of land we can get hold of to fight climate change!). Regards, Jim W.

Pete Epanchin

Apr 25, 2015
11:42

Fellow


8 |
Share via:
Hi Jim, Interesting proposal. Thanks for submitting and please do keep iterating on it! I wanted to share a few thoughts that might help spur on further creative thinking and perhaps an improved proposal. If I understand correctly, the main action you are proposing is the database. What information would go into the database? What are the variables? How would the data be analyzed and used to inform and prioritize action? Your proposal includes several sector-specific (transport, water, etc) recommendations. I didn't follow how those relate to the database. I was also confused by the specificity of activities given the global nature of this database, and the contexts for needs and design would be different across geographies and local realities. Developing and populating a database that covers the non-ocean world at the resolution you propose is ambitious. Were a crowd sourcing model for populating the database be used, and if people were to engage it, the database could populate quickly and be updated regularly. Something to consider. Best, Pete

Jim Wright

Apr 27, 2015
07:42

Member


9 |
Share via:
Proposal
contributor
Hi, Pete, I am amazed at the encouragement I (and no doubt every other contestant) have received in preparing a proposal. I am currently rewriting my proposal off-line (so that I can keep focus) but it will take note of helpful remarks from people like Hannah and yourself. All land areas in the world have multiple usages, some of which support each other and others which are in conflict. Some are doing OK but others will need changes to optimise their role in combatting climate change. Essentially, my database will provide the hooks which will allow information from all sorts of sources to me amalgamated under a single BLU ID. The structure of the information will be specific to the current usages and analytical procedures will need to be developed to determine what, if anything, needs to be done in particular places. My proposal will describe the core database (describing the BLUs), but I am also going to provide a sample project regarding which there is a fair amount of data already available. This will be a carbon capture project, using C4 carbon plants which lock carbon into the soil. There have already been a couple of major projects like this in Mongolia and Africa, but I am going to try and localise it for inhabitants and volunteers (perhaps crowdsourced). The transport and other ideas I mentioned are related to population redistribution, which I see as another possible means of reducing carbon dissemination, but for the moment I will (perhaps) include them only as an illustration of other longterm possibilities. Regards, Jim W.

Keith Alverson

May 5, 2015
04:43

Judge


10 |
Share via:
Glad to see you are thinking big, but I fear this is just too big. A few thoughts: There are a number of relevant databases already. FOr example UNEP/WRI's forestwatch keeps track in real time of forest cover, indicating areas of deforestation in red so you can go see what is going on there. ICRAF maintains a database of soil properties in Africa, helpful in farming and decisions on land management and fertilizer requirements. IPCC maintains a database of past climate measurements and future projections. Different municipalities have landuse, planning, disaster risk and management GIS databases both for land and coastal zones. There are very, very many. It is unclear to me how a global database of everything could be tractable or would be useful. Who would build or maintain it? Who would use it? My main proposal is to think about a tractable problem, both in scope and geographic scale and offer a clear solution to it through a database, including clearly indicating costing and infrastructure required to set it up, and maintain and update it over the long term.

Jim Wright

May 6, 2015
02:58

Member


11 |
Share via:
Proposal
contributor
Thank you for your comments. I am in the course of rewriting my proposal, taking account of the comments already made. I will take due notice of your welcome comments, too. My database is not a comprehensive information centre, which will replace other databases already in existence. Rather, it is more like a directory and is intended to localise all of the information available worldwide, so that people on the site can take charge of their climate amelioration projects on a scale that they can handle. Hopefully, they will be able to go to all of the databases you mention and, using their GPS data to zero in on the information they want and make their own decisions as to how to achieve the improvement or recovery targets they are looking for. They will also be able to search their own database for other locations with similar characteristics and learn from their operations (whether successful or not). I am familiar with some of the remediation work carried out in Africa and Asia by the likes of Robert Vincin and Tony Rinaudo. The former did a lot of work for the Mongolian government, recovering many thousands of hectares of damaged grazing land. The latter recovered a lot of land in Africa by reinstating woodland, but some of this was promptly cut down again by natives to sell and to make the land available for growing vegetables. From a cursory examination of your references, the data appears to be held by governments and other large organisations who undertake large-scale projects. I see my proposal as being complementary, providing help to local people in smaller areas to achieve similar results. My proposal will hopefully include a trial project (possibly using C4 carbon plants) as a proof of concept. Regards, Jim W.

Jim Wright

May 21, 2015
01:45

Member


12 |
Share via:
Proposal
contributor
My rewritten proposal will shortly be mounted, with a focus entirely on the audit database itself, which will be considered to be more of an aid to proposals and projects in a wide variety of fields, including adaptation, of course. I would like to rename my proposal "A Powerful Tool For Worldwide Adaptation Initiatives", but unless someone can advise me how to change the name of the proposal, I shall have to delete it and create a brand new one. My general thesis is that every piece of land in the world (and the oceans too!) must be considered a candidate for a contribution to climate change amelioration. Not all of them will qualify, because they already have important usages that we must keep, but a very large number will be capable either of improvement or adaptation. The database will hopefully be an aggregator of all available information to maximise these aims. Regards, Jim W.