Skip navigation
10comments
Share conversation: Share via:

Shawn Hesse

May 7, 2014
01:00

Fellow


1 |
Share via:
Thanks for your contribution! Here are some thoughts for you as you finish out the proposal; 1) Identify a specific group that will need to take this action 2) Be as specific as possible with the plant selection and their benefits - Check out the work of Kamal Meattle as a starting point - http://www.ted.com/talks/kamal_meattle_on_how_to_grow_your_own_fresh_air 3) Be sure to completely fill out all of the required fields so the judges get a full understanding of your idea. Thanks again, and good luck!

Patrick Sullivan

May 7, 2014
10:36

Member


2 |
Share via:
This idea seems like it may effect building structure. I like your idea.

Vishal Bhavsar

Jun 11, 2014
11:00

Catalyst


3 |
Share via:
Thanks for the proposal. The idea of planting trees and creating urban resilience has been tried by many cities and countries. One point I would like to make is there are two approaches required: a) There is huge building stock and areas already developed. How do you increase tree cover, other open area available within the buildings and around buildings. Also how these activities will impact the structural aspects. There are concepts of roof-top farming. These can be looked and evaluated in greater details. b) New buildings and areas to be developed. There is tremendous opportunity here. You need to see how these aspects can be integrated in the projects from day 0. There has to be multi-displinary team looking at this element and projects should maximise the usage of plants/tree to build resilient assets and cities You can give one each example and propose costing and resource requirements for these interventions. I suggest you work with a developer to bring more realistic paramters of decision making which will help the proposal to be read by the reviewer team.

Felipe De Leon

Jun 17, 2014
06:24

Member


4 |
Share via:
Hi webstersletter, There are many obvious benefits of having more plants in our urban environments, and you mention a few of them in your Proposal. However, I would suggest you need to be more specific regarding what you want to implement and how. A strong Proposal requires more than a great idea. It requires a clear pathway to implement it. Good luck!

Mukesh Gupta

Jun 18, 2014
01:30

Catalyst


5 |
Share via:
Agree with the above comments. You need to provide a clear pathway how to materialize this novel idea into action. Good luck!

Angélica Lara P.r.

Jun 18, 2014
05:16

Fellow


6 |
Share via:
Hi, I'm pretty sure this is a great idea, but you need to work harder to finish it.. I dont know if my comment could help.. I'm thinking about two important initiatives: Green roofs. the benefit of green roofs is that consumption of a building or home into electricity by the use of air conditioning and / or heating decreases the regulatory effect of the new roof, which means less pollution. In addition, green roofs can be used as recreation areas and even provide economic benefits if they harvest. Green walls. the benefits of this initiative are: living walls may also be a means for water reuse; reduction of the urban heat island effect; improved exterior air quality; and noise reduction. Regards

Abigail Derby Lewis

Jun 19, 2014
10:51

Catalyst


7 |
Share via:
Great start to a proposal! I suggest to flesh it out in more ecological detail. It's important to understand and consider the ecology of a system before we start arranging or re-arranging how we manage it. Invasive species like Kudzu are problematic because they can aggressively take over and dominate a system, turning it into a monocrop. Diversity in our natural systems is key to long-term resiliency of that system. Restoring the health and functionality of at least portions of the natural systems that occurred in a particular urban center will ultimately yield more robust benefits. Non-native species sometimes must be used as well, due to the nature of the challenging conditions of urban areas (compacted soil, heat stress, etc.), but a balance is desirable. The co-benefits of these diverse systems is that they provide habitat for many birds, mammals, insects etc., which a monocrop of Kudzu, or any other invasive species, often do not. Hope this is helpful, and that you can incorporate more of the ecology premise into the proposal. Best of luck and I look forward to reading your final proposal!

Tomas Brage

Jun 20, 2014
05:06

Fellow


8 |
Share via:
Thank you for your proposal!, I hope you have picked up some useful ideas from all the comments above in order to complete your proposal! I would encourage you to develop your ideas looking at how a green cover for buildings would directly or indirectly enhance the resilience of any given urban environment. For instance, by creating less energy-dependant communities? Good luck developing your project!

Carolina Collaro

Jun 20, 2014
02:19

Member


9 |
Share via:
Hi, you chose to put the proposition in the field of urban resilience, so it takes a reference to urban! council to look better policies on green-infrastructures and also to those of urban ecosystem services and why not? but maybe you know more than us .. the urban agriculture viewpoint, and the rural-urban fringe report. Even the green-roofs are an idea to develop and to include perhaps in this project.Whishes!

Climate Colab

Aug 6, 2014
12:32

Member


10 |
Share via:
This proposal lacks complete information about how the strategy would result in increased resilience for urban areas.