Skip navigation

Please find below the judging results for your proposal.

Finalist Evaluation

Judges'' comments


This proposal was not selected to advance to the Finalist round.
Comments from Judges:

A map and database of green buildings and their attributes in an area would be useful, and the idea of quantifying the sustainability benefits could provide useful demonstrations of the effects of greening. The difficulty would be firstly, in obtaining reliable data, and secondly, in trying to quantify the impact - crowd sourcing is unlikely to result in accurate performance figures. The other big question is how would the public be drawn to the site? The site would have relevance for designers and governmental uses, but it is not clear how it would stimulate or inspire the public. The costs relative to the potential user impact would seem to be fairly high, especially as it is an on-going programme that would need to be managed and updated over time.

Semi-Finalist Evaluation

Judges'' ratings


Novelty:
Feasibility:
Impact:
Presentation:

Judges'' comments


Very interesting idea with lots of potential. The drivers for government and research use seems clear but it is not clear how the public would make use of this data. What kind of interface it would have that would drive people to use this site? The marketing component could be move developed to clarify how it would engage and impact consumers. A potential barrier for consideration includes availability of building use data. Building owners often do not want to share data or even basic information on the features of their buildings. Even certifiers of green buildings are often not able to share information about the buildings they certify as building owners do not allow it to be public. Further, by law, building owners often do not have access to the energy usage of their tenants. Similarly, to what degree are every roof-top and distributed solar installation available via public record? Tracking the total number of tons of avoided CO2 would also be challenging in locations without mandatory public disclosure requirements (currently most of these only address public and commercial buildings).

Great project idea and with its open access approach it could have far-reaching impact, particularly where there is limited budget to pursue green initiaitives that would requite extensive research and time. I note that some additional focus on how to promote the project for the greatest possible uptake -- which could add additional costs -- may be a challenge to how far and wide it could be used.

0comments
Share conversation: Share via:
No comments have been posted.