Skip navigation
3comments
Share conversation: Share via:

2013ag/forestryjudges 2013ag/forestryjudges

Jul 3, 2013
01:54

Judge


1 |
Share via:
(1) Good description of feasibility. (2) It is a project targeted speifically at sub-Saharan Africa area. It is novel in providing support to that region. (3) No estimation yet of CC reduction- please provide (4) No diagrams, figures, charts, etc- would really strengthen proposal.

Dong-gill Kim

Jul 19, 2013
02:18

Catalyst


2 |
Share via:
Proposal
contributor
Dear Judge: Thank you very much for your thoughtful comments and advice. We found your comments and advice were very useful and we revised our application accordingly. Thanks again and best regards, Dong-Gill Kim on behalf of team AFRI AGFO

2013ag/forestryjudges 2013ag/forestryjudges

Jul 29, 2013
11:03

Judge


3 |
Share via:
The overall concept associated with this proposal is good, however, the mechanism described to truly sequester significant quantities of carbon needs some work. Assuming easy adaptation to the proposed methods should not be taken for granted. We suggest to include a model that shows how this could scale from test plot to regional, as well as a proposed model for changes to microclimate (nested model).